Toronto! Bring out your Casseroles, Once More for Your Right to Think Aloud!

 

Today there will be a call-out for concerned citizens to come downtown to show support for a young man who spoke out in what is supposed to be a country made for speaking out. He didn’t assault, attack, rob or steal, or really commit any crime aside from relaying a nonviolent message that he believes in. To be allowed to speak out is a right most consider natural, human. We’re raised, and told we have the right to Free Speech, but more and more, using it is getting the prominent members of movements jailed and fined.

Radio-Canada Interview, May 13th 2012

“I think that it is completely legitimate for students to undertake the means necessary to respect the democratic choice to strike… It’s completely regrettable that a minority of students are using the courts to go around decisions that were made collectively. If students need to form picket lines to ensure that their strike votes are respected, we think that’s completely legitimate.”

– Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois,

 

When Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois incited the protesters in Quebec despite court order to take up a picket line to enforce a majority vote to strike, he was found guilty of contempt of court, which carries a $5000 fine and a year in prison. Protesting a school isn’t like protesting against a company you do or do not work for. It receives heavy subsidization, and is a key asset required to gain employment in society’s full range of activities, and because of these two facts it should be considered on whole a public asset. He has more right to speak out about his institutions than if it were say, a fitness club where attendance and success are not necessary but because also they are not paid by public funding. What counts here is does he have the right to say the best or correct action is to block the school.

Students don’t all support their unions, or their unions decisions, but they all benefit from the actions of a strong union. It seems reasonable that they should have a basic relationship between the active and inactive members of the union. A picket line where students can get in but not without hearing the messages from the angry mobs outside fighting for their and their childrens’ education and rights seems like a reasonable kind of failsafe for any educational facility. Its just part of free speech.

But he’s not being arrested for being in the picket line, he’s not being arrested for saying people should make one. He’s being jailed for saying the union’s position on the matter is that people should have the right to enforce their votes by creating picket lines, that this is a legitimate move. Being that he was the spokesperson for the union, he was certainly going to be the one to say something, and so regardless of his personal opinion, his job was to announce the organization felt it was correct that people should make a line to radically and non-violently create an impression. It should never be illegal for people to express such a benign and human position. Its not a problem with what he believes though, instead it is a mechanical trap of a rule. He broke the rule, so he pays the price. Basic decency should remind any judge that whether they had a right to form a picket, Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois has a right to say what he feels or what his organization has voted upon. He can not reasonably be found legally responsible for other people by making a simple announcement as he was as his role as spokesperson dictated. his opinion was not violent, racist, or of any other filthy nature. A bit of discomfort felt by students entering the schools must surely be worth preserving freedom of speech, the right to say what you think is right, the right to stand out in a crowd. Otherwise, I can think of a whole spectrum of subcultures within society that say contrary things, this judge would have to imprison all the underground hip-hop artists, of course. Generally speaking, and unless absolutely necessary, no law should trump a basic right like this ruling has.

If this doesn’t ring home, think about how law works. Precedent. Once something is ruled a certain way it is referred upon and lodges itself deeper into the legal system, adapted for new uses. This Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois guy was just a guy who got involved in extra-curricular activities in his school, arrested essentially for thought crime and charged a pretty hefty sum of money to boot. This is not a question of legal authority, this imprisonment has been committed in order to create fear in the minds of all who would think to oppose the status quo.

The march starts at Dufferin Grove Park today at 12pm – 2pm

Facebook event is here, invite yourself: https://www.facebook.com/events/164380417036919/

The legal defense website: http://appelatous.org/

Advertisements

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About MediaWrench

MediaWrench is a grassroots, civilian journalism group that seeks to give a voice to those mainly ignored or misrepresented by the mainstream media. Through written and digital medium, we provide a timeline of the events and phenomena that matter the most to you, while also bringing entertainment. We collectively seek to promote social awareness, sustainable living, and a culture of inclusivity worldwide, and we especially invite you to discuss what you've read - We want to hear it!

2 responses to “Toronto! Bring out your Casseroles, Once More for Your Right to Think Aloud!”

  1. Karen says :

    I Believe article, “Toronto! Bring out your Casseroles, Once More for Your Right
    to Think Aloud! Media Wrench” was in fact really good!
    I reallycould not see eye to eye together with
    u more! At last appears like Idiscovered a website really worth checking out.
    Many thanks, Nikole

    • MediaWrench says :

      Hey thanks!
      ‘means a lot to me, I wish more people would give feedback it really feeds the fuel used to make more content.
      I wrote that article myself, in response to the increasing militarization of police and criminalization of dissent; I’m glad it moved you.

      This year should be a good one for civilian journalism, and the year we’ve been doing this has led to exciting new opportunities interviewing important people that perhaps one day the historians will try to erase. The recent piece about Permaculture is just the first in a proposed series to stretch through Summer, and on April the 20th there will be politicians from all the major parties (well, except the blue guys) speaking about legalization of a certain medicinal item, I’m hoping to get some firsthand coverage of the speaking and gathering. I believe there should be some form of anarchist march coming up as well, and those are always entertaining (you can find a video of last years’ march/run/evade on our youtube channel link below). So, lots to check out.
      Also you can find a lot more (60+) of our videos on http://www.youtube.com/mediawrench the twitter account is @mediawrench and we keep a facebook as well: http://www.facebook.com/mediawrench
      Take care!
      Kris

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: